Table 20.1
Sovereign Acts in Direct and Representative Democracies
Act of sovereignty Swiss "direct democracy" U.S.-European "representative democracy"
Pass a law People may have direct vote People have no direct role
Challenge a law passed by parliament or congress People can do directly (referendum) People cannot do directly; a law can be challenged only through their representatives
Pass a treaty Requires popular vote No role for popular vote at all unless government desires it as a special measure
Alter the constitution People can do directly with no elite support (initiative) and must approve for any change to be made Some elite must initiate (Congress or convention) and a direct popular vote plays no role (ratification is by 3/4 of state legislatures)
Choose chief executive People vote only through parliament People vote directly (in some countries) or more directly (in the U.S.)
Send criminal to jail People through a randomly selected jury People through a randomly selected jury
Confer citizenship Popular (communal or cantonal) vote Decision of magistrate (usually unelected)
Declare federal law unconstitutional Arguably impossible; in practice happens only when constitution is altered—which requires a popular vote Can be done by unelected court (U.S., Germany, France, other)