Russian and Ukrainian Philosophy
Philosophy 270
Dr. Eugene Lashchyk
Syllabus
Fall 1992
- Course objectives:
- The course aims to introduce the students to the
central figures in Russian and Ukrainian philosophy.
- The official philosophy of dialectical materialism
as it functioned from 1918-1990 in the former Soviet Union will be
presented. The sometimes pernicious effects of an official
philosophy-ideology of Marxism-Leninism on the developments in the
sciences and the humanities will be shown.
- Textbooks:
- (eds.) James M. Edie, James P. Scanlan, Mary-Barbara Zeldin,
and George L. Kline, Russian Philosophy, Vol. I-III
(University of Tennessee Press, 1987).
- Fyodor Dostoyevsky,
The Idiot (A Signet
Classic, 1980), (written in 1868-1869).
- Handouts: Supplementary readings.
- Selections in Ukrainian Philosophy
- Taras Zakydalsky, "Introduction" and Ch. 1: "Interpretation of
Skovoroda's Thought" from The Theory of Man in the Philosophy of
Skovoroda, M.A. thesis in philosophy, Bryn Mawr College, 1965.
pp. 1-36
- Dan B. Chopyk, "Skovoroda's Fables: Analysis" and "Skovorodas
Fables" from Gregory Skovoroda: Fables and Aphorisms(Peter
Lang, 1990): pp. 70-130.
- Eugene Lashchyk, "Vynnycenko's Philosophy of
Happiness" from Annals of the Ukrainian Academy of Arts and
Sciences Vol. XVI (1984): pp. 289-326.
- John Fizer, "The Essential Being Of the Work of
Poetic Art" and "Conclusion," from Alexander A.Potebnja's
Psycholinguistic Theory of Literature (1986): pp. 1-50;
pp.133-140
- Mychailo Tuhan-Baranovsky, "The Influence of
Ideas of Political Economy on the Natural Sciences and Philosophy
(1918)," from Annals of the Ukrainian Academy of Arts and
Sciences Vol. XIII (1973-1977): pp. 190-208.
- Eugene Lashchyk, "Some Reflections on the
Relationship between Philosophy and
Economics (A Commentary on Tuhan-
Baranovsky's article)," Annals of the Ukrainian Academy of Arts
and Sciences Vol. XIII (1973-1977): pp. 217-237.
- Eugene Lashchyk and Taras Zakydalsky, Review of
Filosofs'ka Dumka from Recenzia (1975): pp. 34-45
- Selections from Russian and Soviet Philosophy
- Taras Zakydalsky, "Ch. 3: The Moral Argument,"
from N. F. Fyodorov's Philosophy of Physical Resurrection,
Ph. D. dissertation, Bryn Mawr College, 1976, pp. 154-253.
- Leszek Kolakowski, "The Rise of Leninism,"
from Main Currents of Marxism pp. 381-412
- Loren R. Graham, "Ch. 1: Historical Overview", "Ch. 2:
Dialectical Materialism in the Soviet Union: Its Development as a
Philosophy of Science," and "Ch. 4: Genetics," from Science,
Philosophy, and Human Behavior in the Soviet Union (New York:
Columbia University Press, 1987): pp.1-66; 102-155
- Eugene Lashchyk, "Soviet Philosophy Under Gorbachev,"
from Ukrainian Affairs (1987): pp.7-8.
- Course Requirements:
One term paper, a mid-term and final
examination each worth thirty percent. Class reports and class
participation will make up the remaining ten percent.
- Course outline:
- Week of Sept. 10
- Descriptions of course and Historical Background of Russia and
Ukraine.
- Week of Sept. 14
- Philosophy in the Kievo-Mohylanska Academy.
- Read: Zakydalsky 1965, pp. 1-36; Edie I, 1987, pp. 3-10.
- Week of Sept. 21
- The outlines of Skovoroda's philosophy of man, ethics and
metaphysics, and a discussion of Skovoroda's dialogue on the nature
of happiness.
- Read: Edie I 1987, pp. 11-62.
- Week of Sept. 28
- Continue a discussion of the dialogue and a comparison of
Skovoroda's theory of human nature and happiness with such
philosophers as Plato, Aristotle, St. Thomas, Bentham, Sartre, and
Margolis.
- Read: Zenkovsky I, pp. 53-64. (Reserve)
- Week of Oct. 5
- Skovoroda's fables and their interpretation.
The beginnings of Russian philosophy: Alexander Radishchev
(1749-1802) "Man's immortality."
- Read: Chopyk 1990, Fables,
pp.70-130; Edie I (1987), pp. 77-100.
- Week of Oct. 12
- Radishchev on the immorality of serfdom. Nicholas Fyodorov
(1828-1903) "Man's immortality put on a scientific basis."
- Read: Edie I (pp. 63-77); Edie III (1987), Fyodorov, pp. 1-55.
- Week of Oct. 19
- Fyodorov on the moral task of physical resurrection. Th.
Alexander A. Potebnja the Ukrainian philosopher of language
- Read: Zakydalsky (1976), pp. 154-253; Fizer (1986), pp. 1-25.
- Week of Oct. 26 Mon.
- Continue with Potebnja;
- Tuesday, Oct. 27
- In lieu of class go to lecture on
"Potebnja: Linguistics As a Key to Our Understanding of Reality" by
Prof. Ivan Fizer, 12:30, Wister Philosophy Lounge
-
Thursday, Oct.29
- Mid-Term Examination
-
Week of Nov. 2 Mon.
- Mid-Semester Holiday
- Tu. & Th.,
- Dostoyevsky, The Idiot; Edie II, Dostoyevsky, pp.
235-239; 240-249, "Notes from the Underground."
-
Week of Nov. 9
- Nicholas Berdyaev, The Philosophy of
Personalism, and Existentialism.
- Read Edie III, Berdyaev, pp. 143-220.
- Week of Nov. 16
- Soviet Philosophy - Dialectical Materialism and science:
Conflict or Harmony?
- Read: Loren Graham 1987, pp. 1-66;
102-155; Edie III, Spirkin, 464-508.
- Week of Nov 23
- Lenin's Materialism and Empirio-Criticism and his views on an
independent labor movement.
- Read: Edie III, Lenin selections,
pp. 410-436; Kolakowski, The Rise of Leninism, pp. 381-412; Edie
III, Axelrod, pp. 455-463.
- Nov. 25-28
- Thanksgiving Holidays
- Week of Nov. 30
- Term Paper due
- Ukrainian Philosophy - Tuhan-Baranovsky: How one science
influences another - Discussion and Critique.
- Read: Tuhan-
Baranovsky, 1918, pp. 189-208.
Lashchyk (1977), pp. 217-237.
-
Week of Dec 7
- The periodization of Ukrainian philosophy: the Soviet Period;
Volodymyr Vynnycenko's Philosophy of Happiness.
- Read: Lashchyk
1975, Review of Filosofs'ka Dumka.
- Lashchyk 1987,
"Soviet Philosophy Under Gorbachev"
- Lashchyk 1984, "Vynnycenko's Philosophy of Happiness"
-
Mon Dec 14
- Last day of class. A Comparison of three moral systems:
Christian, socialist and Vynnycenko's.
- Final Exam
Term Paper Assignment
Write a ten page double spaced paper on one of the topics listed
below. Your paper should have footnotes and bibliography.
An online search is recommended in our library to get a good sample
of work that has already been done, These bibliographical searches
produce abstracts of the relevant material. Please submit a copy
of the bibliographical search together with your paper. In order
to run the on line search, the library requires that you attend a
one hour lecture. See the library info desk for schedules.
The paper will be worth 30% of your grade.
Term Paper Topics:
- Skovoroda's philosophy of happiness and its possible
similarities to Maslow's theory of self realization.
- Skovoroda's conception of God and its comparison with Spinoza
and/or the views of those who consider God to be feminine.
- Research the evaluation of a moral system and then evaluate
Fyodorov's moral arguments for universal resurrection.
- Trace the influences and possible antecedents of
Fyodorov's universal resurrection. (Bible, Judaism,
Christianity, etc.)
- Compare and/or evaluate Potebnja's view of objective reality
as filtered by the language of a nation or culture and Kuhn's view
that observations are theory laden and/or the Whorf hypothesis.
- Potebnja claims that "poetry, myth and science therefore
coexist in the state of symbiosis"(Fizer p. 77). Delineate the
nature of each of these and discuss the possible symbiosis.
-
Compare Radishchev arguments for immortality with Plato's arguments
as found in the Phaedo. Closely evaluate the cogency of some of
these arguments.
- Radishchev claims that the soul is a force
of nature. Compare this view with some similar but more
contemporary positions (e.g. Theilard de Chardin, etc.)
-
Discuss the success or failure of Dostoyevsky's project to create
a Christ like figure in Prince Mishkin. Is Prince Mishkin or the
Idiot a failure because of his character traits or because of the
rottenness of Russian society.
- Discuss Lenin's position
that democratic worker's movements are a blind force that must be
guided by the communist party. Compare Leninism and the
Catholicism on the question of worker movements. (Hint: Both are
hierarchical).
- Critically evaluate Lenin's epistemological
position.
- Discuss both the positive and the pernicious role
that an ideology like dialectical materialism or Catholicism can
have on developments in science.
- Compare the concept of
harmony or balance in the philosophy of Plato and Vynnycenko. (See
particularly Plato's Republic.)
- Compare and contrast
Vynnycenko's moral system with the Existentialists. Is it fair to
say that Vynnycenko's moral system predates such Existentialist
thinkers as Sartre?
- Discuss and evaluate some of the
theories as to why the Soviet Union collapsed.
- Illustrate
the philosophical pluralism of philosophy in the Soviet Union in
the 1920's.
|