A Moral History
of the
United States Government
July 4, 2004

Dedicated to John Riggi (1917-1992), an honorable man

Land and Liberty

Andrew Chrucky

Revised Sept. 24, 2005.
I look at the history of the United States from the perspective of a person who is forced, in one way or another, to work for a living, as contrasted, for example, to an American Indian who could go anywhere and do anything he wanted. As Rousseau put it: "Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains." Why is this so?

I see myself as a wage-slave. Because some may think I am exaggerating, let me explain. There is a broad sense of the term "slave" such that anyone who is forced to do anything by anyone else is a slave to that person. In this broad sense, children are normally slaves of their parents; wives are often slaves of their husbands; soldier are slaves to their superiors; worker are slaves to their employers; prostitutes are slaves to their pimps.

Slavery, in a narrow or technical sense, applies to the condition of people who are, in some sense, the property of some other person -- with or without the possibility of gaining freedom. The severest form of this condition is chattel slavery in which the master is free to kill the slave.

Slavery is, then, a continuum of conditions, with degrees of restrictions, degrees of penalties, and degrees of freedoms.

In general, as I view it, slavery consists of being forced to do work for someone else. This forcing can be direct or indirect. In civilized societies, all forms of slavery are the results of laws.

Direct slavery occurs where the law stipulates that a particular person is the slave, serf, servant, laborer, or apprentice of another. Some laws allowed people to sell themselves into bondage. An example of this is the American Colonial practice of indentured servitude, whereby for the price of passage to America an immigrant sold himself into servitude for a period ranging from 2 to 7 years.

Indirect slavery occurs when the penalty for not working for someone else is a deprivation of the means for existence -- a deprivation of access to subsistence land.

In the American colonies, it was unlawful to be a vagabond, i.e., a homeless person. Such people were arrested and made into laborers for someone or other. If no one could be found to take them, they were whipped and branded through the right ear. For a third offence, they were executed. As remnants of this policy, the United States still has vagrancy laws.

Direct slavery still exists in the United States in the form of military induction (when invoked). In such an event, a civilian is being forced to become a soldier. If he refuses, he will be imprisoned or, under some circumstances, executed. On the other hand, enlistment into the military is like indentured servitude -- one makes an agreement with the government to serve a number of years (technically it is eight years), and the punishment for breaking such an agreement (with exceptions) is normally imprisonment.

Indirect slavery is the result of a deprivation of access to free subsistence land. The United States does not provide for free access to subsistence land, and in this manner forces everyone to get money for subsistence. Even if one manages to buy some land (or even get it for a nominal fee as was provided by the Homestead Act of 1862), one cannot simply subsist on it, because there are always state property taxes to be paid. And if these taxes are not paid, the land is confiscated by the state.

For this reason alone, it is proper to call the present economic and government system of the United States one of wage-slavery. The ultimate land owner is the government which collects property, sales, income, and other taxes as it sees fit.

In addition, because the government does have an enormous amount of money, it is also the largest employer and buyer. The bulk of its budget -- about half a trillion dollars -- is spent on military agents and tools of enforcement -- airplanes, warships, tanks, bombs, missiles, bullets, and such. Often, the youth who are lured into the military are those who cannot afford to pay for education or job training. This is an "economic draft" which ensures that the United States government will have a steady supply of enforcers and canon fodder, drawn largely from the poor.

Capitalism, as I understand it, is the economic system which makes all land into a sellable and taxable commodity. It is a system which does not recognize an unalienable (unsellable) right to free land -- though such a right is implict in the Declaration of Independence as the unalienable (unsellable) right to the pursuit of happiness. Happiness, in this instance, is nothing more than subsistence, and one cannot subsist in an independent and self-sufficient manner without access to land.

All major peasant uprisings and peasant revolutions have recognized the connection between liberty and free land. And this sentiment was expressed by peasants; not by landlords or merchants (bourgeoise). Landlords simply wanted to maintain possession of their lands, while merchants wanted to purchase land. It was to the advantage of peasants only to have access to free land.

The English, the American, and the French Revolutions were not peasant revolutions -- they were revolutions of the aristocracy against a monarchy. Though there were many peasant and slave revolts throughout history, the first successful revolution of slaves was the Haitian Revolution of 1804. In the 20th century, the Mexican, the Russian, and the Spanish Revolutions are examples of three major peasant revolutions -- and it is not surprising that their slogans were "Tierra y Libertad," "Zemlya y Volya," Land and Liberty.

The purpose of Political Liberty is to foster Economic Liberty. Political liberty is needed to get agreement for economic policies. And although the United States allows more political freedom than any other country, because of media control by corporations, it is extremely hard to get a political consensus about better economic policies. Right now, both domestically and internationally, the United States is against any policy which would give away land for free to anyone, without also making it a sellable commodity. Consequently, the following may be a true generalization of U.S. foreign policy: it is a suffecient reason for U.S. intervention in another country, if that country adopts an agrarian policy of giving away land for free. The underlying reason is that a country of self-sufficient and independent land owners will not yield a pool of cheap wage-slaves, including soldiers, for capitalists.

"In former times the marauding minority of mankind, by means of physical violence, compelled the working majority to render feudal services, or reduced them to a state of slavery or serfdom, or at least made them pay a tribute. Nowadays the dependence of the working classes is secured in a less direct but equally efficacious manner, viz. by means of the superior power of capital; the labourer being forced, in order to get his subsistence, to place his labour power entirely at the disposal of the capitalist. So there is a semblance of liberty; but in reality the labourer is exploited and subjected, because, all the land having been appropriated, he cannot procure his subsistence directly from nature, and, goods being produced for the market and not for the producer's own use, he cannot subsist without capital. Wages will rise above what is wanted for the necessaries of life, where the labourer is able to earn his subsistence on free land, which has not yet become private property. But wherever, in an old and totally occupied country, a body of labouring poor is employed in manufactures, the same law, which we see at work in the struggle for life throughout the organized world, will keep wages at the absolute minimum"

F. A. Lange, Die Arbeiterfrage. Ihre Bedeutung fur Gegenwart und Zukunft. Vierte Auflage. 1861, pp. 12, 13. Quoted by H. J. Nieboer, Slavery: As an Industrial System (Ethnological Researches), 2d edition, 1909, p. 421.

Solution to the Unemployment Problem
A Free Land Amendment to the Constitution of the United States
Each person has a right to free and non-taxable subsistence land.

". . . every man has, by the law of nature, a right to such a waste portion of the earth as is necessary for his subsistence."
Thomas More, Utopia

"Not the constitution, but free land, and its abundance of natural resources open to a fit people, made the democratic type of society in America for three centuries." Frederick Turner, Chapter XI, The West and American Ideals, Frontier in American History.
If a person has no access to land, then that person
  1. must work for someone, or
  2. get charity from someone, or
  3. live by criminal activity, or
  4. starve.
If a person is unemployed and does not want to starve
and does not want charity, then that person must live by
criminal activity.

Economic Democracy = everyone has a right to free private (subsistence) land


". . . overpopulation is critical today and may well make the distribution question moot tomorrow." Paul and Anne Ehrlich, The Population Explosion (1990), p. 21.


Barnes, Peter

  • "The Great American Land Grab," The New Republic (1971-72).
  • "The Vanishing Small Farmer," The New Republic (1971-72).
  • The People's Land, A Reader on Land Reform in the United States, ed. Peter Barnes, Rodale Press, 1975. "Introduction" -- "Buying Back the Land"

    Bassani, Luigi Marco

  • "Life, Liberty, and . . . : Jefferson on Property Rights," Journal of Libertarian Studies Volume 18, no. 1 (Winter 2004), pp. 31–87.

    Beard, Charles A.

  • An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States, 1913. [pdf file]

    Beer, M.

  • (ed. and introduction) The Pioneers of Land Reform: Thomas Spence, William Ogilvie, Thomas Paine, 1920.

    Brown, Jennifer

  • "Ejidos and Comunidades in Oaxaca, Mexico: Impact of the 1992 Reforms" (Fe. 2004). [pdf file]

    Cadbury, George

  • (and Tom Bryan) The Land and the Landless (1908)

    Chomsky, Noam

  • Links to books and excerpts.

    Chrucky, Andrew,

  • "The Greatest Problem in the World," Cub's Roar, Sept. 1985.

    Clark, Ramsey

  • [International Action Center]
  • "Neighborhood Bully: Ramsey Clark on American Militarism" (an interview by Derrick Jensen), November 2000.
  • (and others) Haiti: A Slave Revolution: 200 years after 1804 (2004).

    Commons, John R.,

  • "Horace Greeley and the Working Class Origins of the Republican Party," Political Science Quarterly, XXIV (September, 1909): 468-488.

    Danhof, Clarence H.,

  • "Farm-Making Costs and the 'Safety Valve': 1850-60," Journal of Political Economy, XLIX, 317-359 (June, 1941): 317-359.

    Devyr, Thos. Ainge

  • The Odd Book of the Nineteenth Century, or, "Chivalry" in Modern Days: A Personal Record of Reform Chiefly Land Reform, for the Last Fifty Years, 1882. [pdf file]

    Eayrs, James

  • "The Political Ideas of the English Agrarians, 1775-1815," The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, Vol. XVIII, no. 3, Aug., 1952, pp. 287-302.

    Ehrlich, Paul and Anne,

  • The Population Explosion (1990).

    Fitzhugh, George,

  • Sociology for the South, or, The Failure of Free Society (Richmond, 1854).
  • Cannibals All! or Slaves without Masters (Richmond, 1857).

    Foldvary, Fred E.

  • "Ground Rent Seeking in U.S. Economic History," Nov. 21, 1997.

    Foner, Philip S.

  • History of the Labor Movement in the United States, Volume II: From the Founding of the American Federation of Labor to the Emergence of American Imperialism (New York: International Publisher, 1955, 2d ed. 1975). Chapter 7: Haymarket

    Franklin, Benjamin

  • "Observations Concerning the Increase of Mankind, Peopling of Countries, etc." (1751)

    Fremery, Robert De

  • "Nozick and Locke's Proviso," Land & Liberty, November-December, 1979.

    Friedman, Milton,

  • Capitalism & Freedom, 1961.

    George, Henry (1839-1897)

  • The complete works of Henry George
    1. Progress and poverty.
    2. Social problems.
    3. The land question. Property in land. The condition of labor.
    4. Protection or free trade.
    5. A perplexed philosopher [Herbert Spencer]
    6. The science of political economy, books I and II.
    7. The science of political economy, books III to V. "Moses": a lecture.
    8. Our land and land policy.
    9. The life of Henry George, by his son Henry George, jr
    10. The life of Henry George, by his son Henry George, jr

    Gerassi, John

  • The Great Fear in Latin America, 1963, 1965.
  • "Why the War on Iraq? An Open Letter to the European Peoples," Democracy & Nature: The International Journal of Inclusive Democracy vol.9, no.2, (July 2003).

    Gilbert, Amos

  • A Sketch of the Life of Thomas Skidmore, With Appended Selections from Skidmore's Rights of Man to Property!, Introduced, annotated & edited by Mark A. Lause (Chicago: Charles H. Kerr Publishing Company, 1984).

    Goodrich, Carter, and Sol Davison,

  • "The Wage-Earner in the Westward Movement. I. The Statement of the Problem," Political Science Quarterly, L (June, 1935): 179-180.
  • "II. The Question and the Sources," Political Science Quarterly, LI (March, 1936): 61-116.

    Gutelman, Michel

  • "The Socialization of the Means of Production in Cuba," Chapter 2 of L'Agriculture socialisee a Cuba (Paris: Francois Maspero, 1967).

    Hibbard, B. H.,

  • A History of the Public Land Policies (1925).

    Hobhouse, L. T.,

  • Morals in Evolution: A Study in Comparative Ethics, 1906. (Chapter VII: Class Relations) [pdf file Vol. 1 -- pdf file Vol. 2]

    Humphrey, Thomas J.
    Land and Liberty: Hudson Valley Riots in the Age of Revolution (2004)/

    Hyder, Josephy

  • The Case for Land Nationalisation, 1914. [pdf file]

    Jackson, Helen Hunt

  • A Century of Dishonor: A Sketch of the United States Government's Dealings with some of the Indian Tribes (1885). [PDF FILE]

    Johnson, Chalmers

  • Blowback: The Costs and Consequences of American Empire, 2000. New introduction 2004. -- Google Books

    Kane, Murray

  • "Some Considerations of the Safety Valve Doctrine," Mississippi Valley Historical Review, Vol. XXIII (1936): 169-88.

    Land and Freedom

    Langevin, Mark S.

  • (and Peter Rosset) "Land Reform From Below: The Landless Workers Movement in Brazil" MST (1997).

    Lause, Mark A.

  • "The Hard-Earned Obscurity of Thomas Skidmore," Introduction to A Sketch of the Life of Thomas Skidmore, With Appended Selections from Skidmore's Rights of Man to Property!, Introduced, annotated & edited by Mark A. Lause (Chicago: Charles H. Kerr Publishing Company, 1984).

    Letelier, Orlando

  • "The Chicago Boys in Chile: Economic Freedom's Awfull Toll," The Nation, August 28, 1976.

    Locke, John,

  • An Essay Concerning the True Original, Extent and End of Civil Government: Second Treatise on Government, 1690. (Chapter 5 - Of Property)

    Malefakis, E.

  • Agrarian Reform and Peasant Revolution in Spain, New Haven and London, 1970.

    Malthus, Thomas

  • An Essay on the Principle of Population, as it Affects the Future Improvement of Society with Remarks on the Speculations of Mr. Godwin, M. Condorcet, and Other Writers (1798).

    Masquerier, Lewis

  • Sociology: or, The Reconstruction of Society, Government, and Property. New York, 1877. [pdf file -- "Evans and Land Reform," -- "Sketch of the Land Reform Development, and Life of George Henry Evans "

    Minor, Charles Landon Carter (1835-1903)

  • The Real Lincoln (1901). [pdf file]

    Morris, Richard B. Morris
    Government and Labor in Early America, 1946.


  • "The Civil War in Venezuela: Socialism to the Highest Bidder," June 17, 2006.

    Nieboer, H. J.,

  • Slavery: As an Industrial System (Ethnological Researches), 2d edition, 1909. -- [pdf file -- 1st ed. 1900]

    Ogilvie, William

  • The Right of Property in Land, 1781.

    Ogilvy, Arthur James

  • The Third Factor of Production, 1898. [pdf file]

    Ostrom, Elinor

  • Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge University Press. (1990). ISBN 0-521-40599-8. -- Nobel Lecture -- 2009

    Paine, Thomas

  • Agrarian Justice, 1795-6.

    Parssinen, T. M.

  • "Thomas Spence and the Origins of English Land Nationalization," Journal of the History of Ideas, Vol. 34, No. 1 (Jan. - Mar., 1973), pp. 135-141.

    Patel, Raj

  • Stuffed and Starved: The Hidden Battle for the World Food System. (2008). -- Video - Democracy Now - Part 1 -- Video - Democracy Now - Part 2
  • The Value of Nothing: How to Reshape Market Society and Redefine Democracy. (2009). --Google Books -- Video - Democracy Now

    Phillips, William A.

  • Labor, Land and Law: Search for the Missing Wealth, 1886.

    Pimentel, David and Mario Giampietro,

  • "Food, Land, Population and the U.S. Economy," 1994.

    Reed, John,

  • “What About Mexico?” Masses, June 1914.

    Robbins, Roy M.,

  • "Horace Greeley: Land Reform and Unemployment, 1837-1862," Agricultural History, VII, 18 (January, 1933).
  • Our Landed Heritage: The Public Domain, 1776-1936 (1942).

    Russell, Bertrand

  • Proposed Roads to Freedom: Socialism, Anarchism and Syndicalism, 1919.

    Schafer, Joseph

  • "Some Facts Bearing on the Safety-Valve Theory," Wisconsin Magazine of History, XX (December, 1936): 216-232.
  • "Concerning the Frontier as Safety Valve," Political Science Quarterly, Vol. LII (September, 1937): 407-420.
  • "Was the West a Safety Valve for Labor?" Mississippi Valley Historical Review, XXIV (December, 1937): 299-314 .

    Shannon, Fred A.,
    Economic History of the People of the United States (New York, 1934).

  • "The Homestead Act and the Labor Surplus," American Historical Review, XLI (June, 1936): 637-651.
  • "A Post Mortem on the Labor-Safety-Valve Theory," Agricultural History, XIX (January, 1945): 31-37.

    Skidmore, Thomas

  • The Rights of Man to Property! Being a proposition to make it equal among the adults of the present generation: and to provide for its equal transmission to every individual of each succeeding generation, on arriving at the age of maturity, 1829.

    Smith, Henry Nash,

  • Virgin Land: The American West as Symbol and Myth (1950). -- A Synoptic Hypertext

    Smith, Samuel

  • The Nationalisation of the Land, 1884.
  • Chapter XX: The Garden as Safety Valve

    Spence, Thomas

  • The Real Rights of Man, 1775.
  • The Constitution of Spensonia, 1803.
  • The Political Works of Thomas Spence, edited by H. T. Dickinson, 1982.

    Spengler, Joseph J.,

  • "Population Doctrines in the United States. I. Anti-Malthusianism," Journal of Political Economy, XLI (August, 1933): 433-467
  • "II. Malthusianism," XLI (October, 1933): 639-672.

    Stavenhagen, Rodolfo

  • "Social Aspects of Agrarian Structure in Mexico," in Agrarian Problems and Peasant Movements in Latin America, edited by Rodolfo Stavenhagen, 1970.

    Stern, Bernhard J., William Linn Westermann, Melvin M. Knight, Mary Wilhelmine Williams, Ulrich B. Phillips

  • "Slavery," in Encyclopaedia of the Social Sciences, 15 vols., editor-in-chief, Edwin R. A. Seligman (New York: The Macmillan Company, 1930-1935, Reissued 1937.)

    Swartz, Clarence Lee

  • "VI. Land and Rent," What is Mutualism? (1927).

    Taft, Philip

  • (and Philip Ross) "American Labor Violence: Its Causes, Character, and Outcome," The History of Violence in America: A Report to the National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence, ed. Hugh Davis Graham and Ted Robert Gurr, 1969.

    Thackery, S. W.

  • The Land and the Community, 1889. [pdf file]

    Thirsk, Joan

  • Alternative Agriculture: A History From the Black Death to the Present Day (Oxford University Press, 1997).

    Trefzger, Douglas W.

  • "Guatemala's 1952 Agrarian Reform Law: A Critical Reassessment," International Social Science Review, Spring-Summer, 3/22/2002.

    Turner, Frederick Jackson,

  • The Frontier In American History (1921).

    Wallace, Alfred Russel

  • Land nationalisation, its necessity and its aims; being a comparison of the system of landlord and tenant with that of occupying ownership in their influence on the well-being of the people; with appendix on the nationalisation of house property, 1882. [pdf file]

    Ward, Cyrenus Osborne

  • A Labor Catechism of Political Economy (1878). -- [pdf file]
  • The Ancient Lowly: A History of the Ancient Working People from the Earliest Known Period to the Adoption of Christianity by Constantine, Vol. I (1888). -- [pdf file]
  • The equilibration of human aptitudes and powers of adaptation (1895). -- [pdf file]
  • The Ancient Lowly, Vol. II (1900). -- [pdf file]

    White, Matthew,

  • Political Violence in America [in the 20th Century] (website) -- part of The Historical Atlas of the Twentieth Century

    Wicksteed, Charles

  • Our Mother Earth: A Short Statement of the Case for Land Nationalisation, 189?. [pdf file]


  • Aboriginal Land Claims
  • Agrarian Reform
  • Land Reform
  • Land Rights

    Wilson, Roland Knyvet

  • Individualism and the Land Question, 1912. [pdf file]

    Woodward, C. Vann

  • "George Fitzhugh, Sui Generi," Introductory essay to George Fitzhugh's book Cannibals All! or, Slaves Without Masters (1857), 1960.

    World History Archives

    Zandt, Roland Van,

  • "Horace Greeley, Agrarian Exponent of American Idealism," Rural Sociology, XIII, [411]-419 (December, 1948).

    Zinn, Howard

  • A People's History of the United States, 1980.